I’m Still Standing → Stefan and Melissa
mysticmelissa:
A frown etched it’s way onto Melissa’s face as he talked, and she knew she couldn’t do anything for him but make it worse. That’s really all she’d been doing since she’d walked into his life all those months ago. They had both started off pretending, hiding who they were. Melissa out of fear of what would happen and Stefan because well, you didn’t go around telling people you were a vampire. And then a weird friendship, at least on Melissa’s part, started. She’d figured out after awhile that the only use she possibly was to him was her magic, but it made her feel important. Useful. Something she hadn’t felt in a long time. But then her feelings started to grow and while she’d later learn he couldn’t feel a thing, she figured she was feeling enough for the both of them. But Stefan would never be able to reciprocate is what Damon had told her. She was being stupid. Even Stefan had said it before.
“I’m sorry,” she answered, still frowning. Melissa wanted to push him to talk, but that probably wasn’t going to get her anywhere. If he didn’t want to elaborate, he wasn’t going to. She sighed slightly as his arm tightened and he kissed the top of her head. It was probably more out of reflex than anything, but she still found herself leaning into him more. “One day you’ll get out of it, Stefan. Maybe soon, maybe I’ll be long gone and won’t get to see it, but you’ll be free. You deserve to be happy. And don’t argue that,” she said, putting a hand over his mouth to keep him from talking. “I know. I get the whole ‘I’m a monster’ thing. I say the same thing all the time. But this is who we are. And I’ve slowly been learning that we shouldn’t let it be the thing that defines us.” She pulled her hand back and placed it back in his. “We’re more than just monsters. I know that you do or you will regret the things you’ve done. I won’t speak for everyone else, but with me, you’re forgiven. The things that have happened to me have only made me stronger.”
She tilted her head some to look up at him, smiling slightly, and nodded. “The dark magic thing still scares me. But I’m not going to give up on controlling it.” In a first, Melissa felt like she was talking way too much for once. She wondered what Stefan was thinking about, but wouldn’t press it. Instead she put her head back on his shoulder and closed her eyes. She had missed this, the closeness. All of their good memories were being like this. And all of Melissa’s best nights were spent in his arms. Even if he couldn’t feel, he had managed to make her finally feel wanted for more than just what she could do in bed. “You’ll be fine, too. We both will,” she said, tightening her hands around his.
For a moment, her heart picked up, and she wondered if Stefan still noticed that. Melissa just wanted to finally tell him. To finally get it out there. But she was nervous. She’d been steeling herself in preparation for not hearing it back. That was inevitable. But she was hoping it wouldn’t get her left alone. Turning her head again, she looked up at Stefan. “I love you,” she said clearly, mustering up everything she had not to just pass out instead.
It was difficult to keep from rolling his eyes or getting outwardly frustrated with Melissa as she started giving him some sort of pseudo pep-talk. He was tired of hearing that he’d be fine, or that things would get better. When someone was at their lowest, they didn’t want to hear about how much better it could get. But getting upset with Melissa wouldn’t accomplish anything at this point. The last time they’d been around each other had basically turned into a large argument and he just didn’t have the energy or motivation to go through that again. Even if he wasn’t about to believe a single word Melissa was saying. Besides, who was he to tell her that over 150 years of experience told him differently? That a monster was exactly who he was and exactly who he would always be. So instead he just gave a small nod with a somewhat strained half-smile which was probably masked by her hand now covering his mouth anyway. If she wanted to believe that things would get better, then that was her right and he wasn’t about to ruin the hopes of someone still so young.
And just like he didn’t believe that he was anything more than a monster, he also had trouble believing that she forgave him for everything he’d done to her and her life. How could a person forgive all of that? He’d used her, toyed with her emotions, manipulated her, tried to kill her, abused her physically and emotionally, and was constantly putting her life into danger. Those weren’t things someone just forgave. But just like he hadn’t felt like arguing her earlier points, he didn’t feel like arguing this one either. So instead, he simply gave her a small smile and a ‘thank you’. At least she didn’t openly hate him, he thought. Then again, her forgiveness when it was undeserved was almost more difficult to stomach than any open hatred would have been, because at least he knew he deserved the latter.
As she talked about her dark magic, he was glad to hear that she was going to do her best to work with it, to control it. Normally he would have had something preachy about control to say to her, about how it was going to be hard, but so important, and that she shouldn’t just try to silence that side of her. Because silencing a dark side when you had one wasn’t the answer. Learning how to control and accept that part of you was what it would take if she wanted a chance, something he should have tried to do long before now, but he just couldn’t find it in him at the moment to say any of that. He nodded in agreement when she said they’d both be okay, and his arms tightened around her as hers did the same. It was oddly comfortable to have her so close again, to not be talking about a coffin or any murder attempts, and just…be.
The increase in her heartbeat was hard to miss and he wondered what she could possibly have to say that would cause it. He bent his neck to look at her as she looked up at him, and if he’d had a heartbeat, he swore it would have stopped at her words. He loosened his arm from around her before withdrawing it completely as his brow once more furrowed down at her. It wasn’t like this was a completely shocking development. She’d texted the same thing to him once but they both had sort of just brushed over it. It was hard to brush over this situation however and for a moment he was at a complete loss. His emotions these days were constantly teetering between being non-existent and being painful and overwhelming and neither were very conducive to responding to someone who was confessing their love to you. He wanted to tell her no, that she couldn’t and he didn’t want her to. He wanted to send her off and tell her that he’d find a new witch.
But what would that accomplish? It was more than obvious that he felt at least something for Melissa and if this had been any other situation, he would have wanted to explore that. And sure, part of him wanted to chalk up this insanity to some weird form of supernatural Stockholm Syndrome but….what was the worst that could possibly happen from not turning her away? It wasn’t like things could get much worse for either of them. Things were never going to be normal between himself and Elena again so there wasn’t that holding him back. She deserved a chance at some sort of normalcy. Or at least happiness, and he knew now that they’d never be what they had been. And it was just better to leave it as a memory instead of attempt to get it back and butcher everything good they’d once had in the process. But Melissa deserved happiness too and he wasn’t sure she’d ever have that with him either. Then again, it wasn’t as if he was having to decide the rest of his future at that very moment and so instead of continuing to try to make sense of any of this, he instead brought his hand up to gently cup her face as he leaned down and pressed his lips lightly to hers. It wasn’t an ‘I love you’ back, they both knew he wasn’t in any place for that. But it was something. And for the first moment in months, he felt the briefest flicker of something that almost felt like things could possibly end up okay for him.